Senin, 05 Maret 2012

English Cooperative Learning

CHAPTER 1 THE EFFECTIVE TEACHER WHAT IS AN EFFECTIVE TEACHER? The Pole-Mode Definition If you had grown up a century ago, you would have been able to answer “What is an effective teacher?” very simply: A good teacher was good person-a role model who met the community ideal for a good citizen, good parent, and good employee. At the time, teachers were judged primaly on their goodness as people and only secondarily on their behavior in the classroom. They were expected to be honest, hard working, generous, friendly and considerate, and to demonstrate these qualities in their classroom by being organized, disciplined, insightful, and committed. Practically speaking, this mean that to be effective, all a beginning teacher needed was King Solomon’s Wisdom, Sigmund Freud’s insight, Albert Einstein’s knowledge, and Florence Nightingale’s dedication. It soon became evident that this definition of an ideal teacher lacked clear, objective standar of performance that could be consistently applied to all teachers and that could used to train future teachers. The Psychological Characteristics Definition The early role-mode approach soon gave way to another, which attempted to identify the psychological characteristics of a good teachers: personality, attitude, experience, and aptitude/achievement. Table 1.1 list some of these psychological characteristics. Because they have a certain intuitive appeal, it is worth noting way they have not been useful criteria for defining good teachers. Personality. Over the years, only e few personality measures have been developed that relate specifically to teaching. Because most personality measures have been designed to record behavior in clinical setting, much of what they measure has been of lttle help in identifying the positive or normal behaviors that may be needed to be an effective teacher. Consequently, the usefulness of many personality tests in predicting a teacher’s classroom behavoior must be inferred from their more general success in the mental health field. Although certain interpersonal, emotional, and coping behaviors are believed to be required for effective teaching (Levis, 1987), personality tests have provided few insights into the positive social behavior that may be needed for effective teaching. Attitude. While attitude assessments may be either global (e.g.,attitude toward the aducational system and the teaching profession) or specific (e.g., attitude toward a particular task, child, or curriculum), most attempt to measure teacher attitude generally have failed to forecast what a teacher who has a particular attitude actually does in the classroom. Research generally has shown a low and nonsignificant correspondence between teacher attitude and classroom performance (Jakson, 1968; Walberg, 1986). Therefore, the use of attitude data for measuring teacher effectiveness has had to rest on the assumption that attitudes are related to behaviors that are one or more staps removed from the actual teaching process, such as more organized lesson plans or better subject-matter preparation (Clark & Peterson, 1986; Kagan & Tippins, 1992). However, defining effective teaching in this manner always will be less direct and credible than observing actual classroom practices. Experience. You probably, at one time or another, provided biographical data about yourself when applying for a job. You may heve found that a listing of your qualifications, such as years of experience, graduate credits earned, or hours of training defined your experience so broadly as not to be very predictive of what you could do on the specific job. Such descriptions typicslly do not describe experience relevant to performing the day –to-day tasks required in a specific context, such as classroom, grade level, or subject matter area. A teacher’s experience with a specific grade level, curriculum, and type of learner is more relevant actual classroom performance than general biographical data, which represents only a small portion of a teacher’s qualification for a particular teaching assignment. Aptitude and Achievement. Like general experience, most aptitude and achievement data do not accurwtely predict classroom performance. Regardless of the fact that these measures often are used to predict student performance, a teacher’s prior achievement seldom has correlated strongly with classroom performance-and here is why. As an example of prior achievement, consider a teacher’s college grades. Achieving good grades might indicate enthusiasm for teaching and a promise of Good classroom performance. But standars set by training institution require teacher to meet minimum levels of competence for certification. This is usually sufficient to make the small variations in grades among beginning teachers irrelevant to actual performance in the classroom. To summarize, using psychological characteristics to define a good teacher represented an attempt to measure teacher behavior objectively. But these characteristics often were too remote from the teacher’s day-to-day work in classroom to meaningfully contribute to a definition of good teacher. Most notably, these definitions excluded the most important and obvious measure of all for determining good teaching: the performance of the students who are being taught. A New Direction In the last three decades, a revolution has occurred in the definitions of good teaching. We have seen that defining good teachers by community ideals proved unrealistic. We also have seen how teacher’s psychological characteristics to be poorly related to what teachers actually did in the classroom. This directed researchers to study the impact of specific teacher behaviors on the specific cognitive and affective behaviors of their students. The term good teaching changed to affective teaching and the research focus shifted from exclusively studying teachers to include their effects on student. These new ways of studying classroom behavior have made the student and teacher-student interaction in the classroom the focus of modern definitions of affective teaching. Linking Teacher Behavior with Student Performance. During the 1970s and 1980s, researchers developed new methods for studying the interactive patterns of teachers and student. The goal was to discover which teacher behaviors promote desirable student performance. But before unveiling the findings of this research and their implications for effective teaching, let’s see how the research was performed. The Research Process. To collect data on the classroom interaction of teachers and students, researchers often used instruments like those shown in Figures 1.1 to 1.3. These particular instruments, devised by Good and Brophy (1987,1997) for their research on affective teaching, record observations of various student-teacher behaviors. Using the response form in Figure 1.2, the observer codes both student responses to questions and the teacher’s reaction and feedback. For example, in the tenth interchange recorded on this form, a male student falls to answer a question (0), is criticized by the teacher for not answering (-), and then is given the answer by the teacher (Gives ans.). Numbers for the interchanges are assigned as they occur, allowing the pattern of question-answer-feedback to be recoded over an entire class period. In Figure 1.3 the observer codes the student performance being praised by the teacher (perseverance, progress, success, good thinking, etc.). Individual students are identified by assigning each a unique number. This form record not only the praise behavior of the teacher in relation to individual student behavior, but also the overall pattern or sequence of action. For example, student 8 is praised three times in a row for “performance or effort.” With instruments such as these, a rich and varied picture of classroom activity can be captured over the course of a research study. Obviously, a single observation of a single class would be produce too little data to reveal a consistent behavior pattern. However, multiple observation periods extending across different teachers, schools, and school districts can reveal consistent patterns of teacher-student interactions. These patterns of classroom behavior then can be related to student behaviors, such as performance on end-of-year standardized achievement test, specially prepared classroom test, and performance and portfolio assessments to determine the effects of teacher-student interaction performance. Contradictory result or found no relationships among certain types of classroom interactions and student outcomes. But many studies found patterns of interaction that consistently produced desirable student outcomes in the form of higher test scores, increased problem-solving skills, and improved learning skills. Now that you know how the research was conducted, let’s look at the teaching behaviors that researchers agree contribute to effective teaching. FIVE KEY BEHAVIORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE TEACHING Approximately 10 teacher behaviors show promising relationships to desirable student performance, primarily as measured by classroom assessments and standardized test. Five of behaviors have been consistently supported by research studies over the past three decades (Brophy, 1989; Brophy & Good, 1986; Dunkin & Biddle, 1974; Rosenshine, 1971; Teddlie & Stringfield, 1993; Walberg, 1986). Another five have had some support and appear logically related to effective teaching. The first five we will call key behaviors, because they are considered essential for effective teaching. The second five we will call helping behaviors that can be used in combinations to implement the key behaviors. The five key behaviors essential for effective teaching are: 1. Lesson clarity 2. Instructional variety 3. Teacher task orientation 4. Engagement in the learning process 5. Student success rate Lesson Clarity This key behavior refers to how clear a presentation is to the class as indicated in the following, examples: Effective Teachers • Make their points understandable. • Explain concepts clearly so their students are able to follow in a logical step-by-step order • Have an oral delivery that is clear, audible, and free of distracting mannerisms Less Effective Teachers • Use vague, ambiguous, or indefinite language: “might probably be,” “tends to suggest,” “could possibly happen.” • Use overly complicated sentences, such as “there are many important reasons for the start of War World II but some more important than others, so let’s start with those that are thought to be important but really aren’t.” • Give directions that often result in student request for clarification. One result from research on teacher clarity is that teachers very considerably on this behavior. Not all teacher are able to communicate clearly and directly to their student without wandering, speaking above students’ levels of comprehension, or using speech patterns that impair their presentation’s clarity (G. Brown & Wragg, 1993; J. T. Dillon, 1988a; Wilen, 1991). If you teach with a high degree of clarity, you will spend less time doing over material. Your questions will be answered correctly the first time, allowing more time for instruction. Clarity is a complex behavior because it is related to many other so-called cognitive behaviors, such as your organization of the content, lesson familiarity, and delivery strategies (whether you use a discussion, recitation, question-and-answer or small-group format). Nevertheless, research shows that both the cognitive clarity and oral clarity of presentations on cognitive tests of achievement (Marx & Wals, 1988). Table 1.2 summarizes some of the indicators of lesson clarity and teaching strategies you will learn about in this text, especially in chapters 5 (direct instruction), 6 (indirect instruction), and 7 (questioning strategies). Instructional Variety This key behavior refers to the variability of delivery during the presentation of a lesson (Brophy & Good, 1986; Rohrkemper & Corno, 1988). One of the most effective ways of creating variety during instruction is to ask questions. As you will learn in Chapter 7, many different types of questions can be asked, and when integrated into the pacing and sequencing of a lesson, they create meaningful variation (Chuska, 1995; Wilen, 1991). Therefore, the effective teacher needs to know the art of asking question and how to discriminate among different question formats-fact question, process questions, convergent question, and divergent questions. These question types will be introduced in Chapter 7 and expanded on in Chapter 8. Another aspect of variety in teaching is perhaps the most obvious: the use of learning materials, equipment, displays, and space in your classroom. The physical texture and visual variety of ypur classroom can all contribute to instructional variety. This, in turn, influences student achievement on end-of-unit tests, performance assessment, and student engagement in the learning process. For example, some studies found the amount of disruptive behavior to be less in classroom that had more varied activities and materials (Emmer, Evertson, Clements, & Worsham, 1997; Evertson, 1997). Other studies have shown variety to be related to student attention (Lysakowski & Walberg, 1981). Some ways to incorporate variety into your teaching will be presented in Chapter 5 (direct instruction), Chapter 6 (indirect instruction), and Chapter 9 (cooperative learning and the collaborative process). Table 1.3 summarizes some of the indicators of instructional variety and teaching strategies that will be covered in these chapters. Teacher Task Orientation Teacher task orientation is key a behavior that refers to how much classroom time the teacher devotes to the task of teaching an academic subject. The more time dedicated to the task of teaching a specific topic, the greater the opportunity students have to learn. Some task-related questions a teacher must answer are (1) How much time do I spend lecturing, asking question, and encouraging students to inquire or think independently? (2) How much time do I spend organizing for teaching and getting my students ready to learn? And, (3) How much time do I spend assessing my learners’ performance? These questions pertain to how much material is presented, learned, and assessed, as opposed to how much time is delegated to procedural matters. All teachers need to prepare their students to learn and want them to enjoy learning. However. Most researchers agree that student performance has been higher in classrooms with teachers who spent the majority of their time teaching subject-specific content as opposed to devoting large amounts of time to the process and materials that may be needed to acquire the content. It follows that classrooms in which teacher-student interactions focus more on intellectual content that allows their students an opportunity to learn are more likely to have higher rates of achievement (Berliner & Biddle, 1995; Porter, 1993). Also, teachers who are task oriented are highly conversant with topics that are likely to appear on performance assessment and end-of-year achievement tests. This is not to say that these teachers “teach to the test.” Rather, their classroom instruction parallels the instructional goals and curriculum that guide the construction of assessments of student progress. These topics are presented in Chapter 3, which prepares you to write lesson objectives, and Chapter 4, which shows you how to execute them in your classroom. Table 1.4 summarizes some of the indicators of teacher task orientation and teaching strategies that will be covered in these chapters. Engagement in the Learning Process Student engagement in the learning process is a key behavior that refers to the amount of time students devote to learning an academic subject. This is one of the most recently researched teacher behaviors related to student performance. It is related to teacher’s task orientation and to content coverage. A teacher’s task orientation should provide students the greatest possible opportunity to learn the material to be assessed. For example, Table 1.5 shows the results achieved in second-grade reading when the teacher’s task orientation-or time teaching an academic subject-was increased over a 5-week period. Increasing the time devoted to this instructional objective from 4 minutes to 52 minutes a day, over an average of only 25 school days, yielded an increase of 27 percentile points (from 39 to 66) on a standardized achievement test. The researchers who recorded these data indicated that, although such large increase in instructional time might appear unusual, they actually were achieved by teachers in these elementary school classrooms. Distinct from the amount of time you devote to teaching a topic is the time your students will be actively engaged in learning the material. This has been called the engagement rate. Engagement rate is the percentage of time devoted to learning when the student is actually on task, engaged with the instructional materials and benefiting from the activities being presented. Even though a teacher may be task oriented and may provide maximum content coverage, the student may be disengaged. This means that they are not actively thinking about working hard, or using what is being presented (Marx & Wals, 1988; Savage, 1991). Such disengagement can involve an emotional or mental detachment from the lesson that may or may not be obvious. When students jump out of their seats, talk, read a magazine, or leave for the restroom, they obviously are not engaged in instruction. Students also can be disengaged in far more subtle ways, such as looking attentive while their thoughts are many miles away. An unpleasant fact of life is that a quarter of a class may be off task at any one time. Correcting this type of disengagement may be much more difficult, requiring changes in the structure of the task itself and the cognitive demands placed on the learner (N. Bannett & Desforges, 1988; Brophy, 1996; Doyle, 1983). Strategies for composing task and activities that elicit the active participation of your learners are presented in Chapters 5 through 9. Several authors (Evertson, 1995; Tauber, 1990) have contributed useful suggestions for increasing learning time and more importantly, student engagement. Their work, recently updated by Emmer et al, (1997), has provided the following suggestions for teachers to promote student engagement: 1. Set rules that let pupils attend to their personal and procedural needs without obtaining your permission each time. 2. Move around the room to monitor pupil’s seatwork and to communicate your awareness of student progress. 3. Ensure that independent assignments are interesting, worthwhile, and easy enough to be completed by each pupil without your direction. 4. Minimize time-consuming activities such as giving directions and organizing the class for instruction by writing the daily schedule on the board. This will ensure that pupils know where to go and what to do. 5. Make abundant use of resources and activities that are at, or slightly above, a student’s current level of understanding. 6. Avoid timing errors. Act to prevent misbehaviors from occurring or increasing in severity so they do not influence others in the class. These teaching practices have also been found to be beneficial for small groups and independent seatwork (L. Anderson, Stevens, Prawat, and Nickerson, 1988). These and other more specific ways of increasing the engagement rates of students will be explored in Chapters 8 and 9. Table 1.6 summarizes some of the indicators of student engagement and teaching strategies that will be covered in these chapters. Student Success Rate Another key behavior, student success rate refers to the rate at which students understand and correctly complete exercises. A crucial aspect of the research on task orientation and student engagement has been the level of difficulty of the material presented. In these studies, level of the difficultly was measured by the rate at which student understood and correctly completed exercises. Three levels of difficultly are as follows: • High success: The student understands the task and makes only occasional careless errors. • Moderate success: The student has partial understanding but makes some substantive errors. • Low success: The student does not understand the task at all. Findings (Berliner, 1979) indicate that a teacher’s task orientation (instructional time) and student engagement are closely related to student success rate, as shown in Figure 1.4. Instruction that produces a moderate-to-high success rate results in increased performance, because more content is covered at the learner’s current level of understanding. This result was initially found for expository or didactic forms of instruction with which learners are taught basic academic skills most easily learned through practice and reception (Rosenshine, 1986). But, more recent research has extended these findings to thinking skills instruction (Beyer, 1995) and project-based learning (Blumenfeld et al.,1991). Research has also shown that instruction that promotes low error rates (high success) can contribute to increased levels of student self-esteem and to positive attitudes toward the subject matter and the school (Slavin, 1991b). Figure 1.4 Levels of time • The time allocated by the school and curriculum guide to particular content • The time you actually are teaching the content • The time your learners are actively engaged with, thinking about, and working with the content you are teaching • The rate at which your learners are responding correctly to the content taught The average student in typical classroom spends about half of the time working on task that provide the opportunity for high success. But researchers have found that students who spend more than the average time in high-success activities have higher achievement, better retention, and more positive attitudes toward school. These findings have led to the suggestion that students should spend about 60 to70 present of their time on task that allow almost complete understanding of the material being taught with only occasional errors (Brophy & Evertson, 1976a, 1976b; Rosenshine, 1986). Moderate-to-high success rates will produce mastery of the lesson content. But they also can provide the foundation for your students to apply learned knowledge in some practical way, such as thinking critically and independently. This has been the unique contribution of strategies self-directed learning and learning to learn, which will be studied in Chapter 8. These strategies encourage learners to construct their own understanding and meanings from lesson content. They also encourage learners reason, problem solve, think critically about the content they are learning. By varying the complexity and variety of the tasks provided, such strategies provide opportunities for individual patterns of thinking to emerge through various forms of classroom discussion & dialogue (Duffy & Roeher, 1989; Rohrkemper & Corno, 1988). We will learn more about this approach to learning called constructivism, in Chapters 6 and 8. Many teachers devote insufficient time to this stage of learning, which is particularly crucial for attaining the goals of problem solving and critical thinking. A key behavior for the effective teacher is organizing and planning instruction that yields moderate-to-high success rates but then challenges the learner to go beyond the information given. You will discover ways to use moderate-to-high success rates to attain the goals of problem solving and critical thinking in Chapters 6 and 8. Table 1.7 summarizes some of the indicators of student success and teaching strategies that will be covered in these chapters. Summary of Live Key Behaviors The five key behaviors-lesson clarity, instructional variety, teacher task orientation, student engagement, and success rate-are essential for effective teaching. Classroom researchers undoubtedly will discover other effective teaching behaviors and attain a more thorough understanding of those already described. However, for the first time, research has provided a basis for better definitions of effective teaching and for training teachers. These five behaviors are the skeleton of the effective teacher, and the remainder of this text will construct the heart, mind and body of the effective teacher. You learned earlier that there can be no simple answer to the question What is an effective teacher? Many behaviors must be orchestrated into patterns of behavior for your teaching to be effective. The identification of only five behaviors makes teaching appear deceptively simple. However, as the following section will reveal, your success in implementing these five key behaviors in the classroom will be assisted by many other helping behaviors. SOME HELPING BEHAVIORS RELATED TO EFFECTIVE TEACHING To fill out our picture an effective teacher, you also need to adopt other behaviors to help you implement the five key behaviors in your classroom. These behaviors can be thought of as helping behaviors for performing the five key behaviors. Research findings for helping behaviors, although promising, are not as strong and consistent as those that identified the five key behaviors. The research has not identified explicitly how these behaviors should be used. This is why helping behaviors need to be employed in the context of other behaviors to be effective, making them catalysts rather than agents unto themselves. Among this helping behaviors are the following: 1. Using student ideals and contributions 2. Structuring 3. Questioning 4. Probing 5. Teacher affect Used of Student Ideals and Contributions Using student ideals and contributions is a behavior that includes acknowledging, modifying, applying, comparing, and summarizing student responses to promote the goals of a lesson and to encourage student participation. Note how any one of these activities (suggested by Flanders, 1970) could be used in achieving one or more of the five key behaviors: • Acknowledging: Using the student’s idea by the repeating the nouns and logical connectives expressed by him or her (to increase lesson clarity). • Modifying: Using the student’s idea by rephrasing it or conceptualizing it in your words or another student’s words (to create instructional variety). • Applying: Using the student’s idea to each an inference or take the next step in logical analysis of a problem (to increase success rate). • Comparing: Taking a student’s idea and drawing a relationship between it and ideas expressed earlier by the student or another student (to encourage engagement in the learning process). • Summarizing: Using what was said by an individual student or a group of students as a recapitulation or review of concepts taught (to enhance task orientation). More recently, the use of student ideas and contribution has been extended to reasoning, problem solving, and independent thinking. This has been achieved through teacher-mediated dialogue that help learners restructure what was is being learned using their own ideas, experiences, and thought patterns. Teacher-mediated dialogue asks the learner not just to respond to textual material, but to internalize its meaning by elaborating, extending, and commenting on it using learner’s own unique thoughts. In this manner, learners are encouraged to communicate the processes by which they are learning, thereby helping them to construct their own meanings and understandings of the content (Steffe & Gale, 1995). We will present strategies for constructivist teaching and teacher-mediated dialogue in Chapter 6 and 8. Use of student ideas and contributions also can increase a student’s engagement in the learning process. Thus, it has become a frequently used catalyst for helping achieve that key behavior (Emmer et al, 1997). Which of the five ways o using student ideas are in this dialogue? First, by putting Tom’s response graphically on the blackboard, thus teacher applied Tom’s answer by taking it to the next step, constructing a proof. Second, by repeating orally what Tom said, the teacher acknowledged to the entire class the value of Tom’s contribution. And third, by having another student prove the correctness of Tom’s response, a summary of the concept was provided. All this was accomplished from Tom’s simple (and only) utterance. “c2 = a2 + b2.” Research reveals that student ideas and contributions, especially when used in the context of the naturally occurring dialogue of the classroom, are more strongly and consistently related to student engagement then simply approving a student’s answer with “Good!” (Good & Brophy, 1997, p. 146). The standard phrases we use to acknowledge and reward student (“correct,” “good,” “right”) are so overused that they may not always convey the reward intended. Although the use of student ideas looks simple, it takes skill and planning. Even when your response is unplanned, you should be prepared to seize opportunities to incorporate student ideas into your lesson. Structuring Teacher comments made for the purpose of organizing what is to come, or summarizing what has gone before, are called structuring. Used before an instructional activity or question, structuring serves as instructional scaffolding that assists learners in bridging the gap between what they capable of doing on their own and what they are capable of doing with help from the teacher, thereby aiding their understanding and use of the material to be taught. Used at the conclusion of an instructional activity or question, structuring reinforces learned content and places it in proper relation to other content already taught. Both forms of structuring are related to student achievement and are effective catalysts for performing the five key behaviors (Bogolf, 1990; Rosenshine & Meister, 1992). This sequence illustrates some of the many ways that you can use structuring. One way is to signal that a shift in direction or content is about is occur. A clear signal alerts students to the impending change. Without such a signal, students may confuse new content with old, missing the differences. Signals such as “Now that we have studied how pipefish change their color and movements … we will learn ….” help student switch gears and provide a perspective that makes new content more meaningful. Another type of structuring uses emphasis. Can you find a point of emphasis in the previous dialogue? By using the phrase “most important,” this teacher alerts students to the knowledge and understanding expected at the conclusion of this activity. This provides students with an organizer for what is to follow, called an advance organizer. In this instance, the students are clued to consider the factors that extend beyond the color and movement of the pipefish to include how they grow and provide the means for other fish to flourish. This makes the teacher’s final question more meaningful (“Can you think of when this clever strategy might not work, making the pipefish prey to other fish deep below the ocean’s surface”). The students have been clued that such a question might be raised and the generalizations beyond the concepts discussed will be expected, phrases such as Now this is important. We will return to this point later. Remember this. are called verbal markers. They can emphasize your most important points. In addition to verbal markers and advance organizers, the effective teacher organizes a lesson into an activity structure. An activity structure is a set of related tasks that differ in cognitive complexity and that to some degree may be placed under the control of the learner. Activity structures (Marx & Walsh, 1988; Rogolf, 1990) can be built in many ways (e.p., cooperatively, independently) to vary the demands they make on the learner and to give tempo and momentum to a lesson. For the effective teacher, they are an important means for engaging students in the learning process and moving them from simple recall of facts to the higher response levels that require reasoning, critical thinking, and problem-solving behavior. The Art of Questioning Questioning is another important helping behavior. Few other topics have been researched as much as the teacher’s use of questions (G. Brown & Wragg, 1993; Risner, Skeel, & Nicholson, 1992; Wilen, 1991). One of the most important outcomes of research an questioning has been the distinction between content questions and process questions, which we will look at next. Content Questions. Teachers pose content questions to have the student deal directly with the content taught. An example is when a teacher asks a question to see if students can recall and understand specific material. The correct answer is known well in advance by the teacher. It also has been conveyed directly in class, in the text, or both. Few, if any interpretations or alternative meanings of the question are possible. Researchers have used various terms to describe content questions, such as the following: Types of Content Questions • Direct: The question requires no interpretation or alternative meanings. Example: “What is the meaning of the word ancient in the story just read?” • Lower-order: The question requires the recall only of readily available facts, as opposed to generalizations. Example: “What was mechanical breakthrough that gave the cotton gin superiority over all previous machines of its types?” • Convergent: Different data sources lead to the same answer. Example: “What is one of the chemical elements in the air we breathe?” • Closed: The question has no possible alternative answers or interpretations. Example: “What is the function of a CPU in a microcomputer?” • Fact: The question requires the recall only of discrete pieces of well-accepted knowledge. Example: “What is the result of the number 47 divided by 6?” Some estimates have suggested that up to 80% of the questions teachers ask refer directly to specific content and have readily discernible and unambiguous correct answer (Gall, 1984; Risner et al., 1992). The even more important is the fact that approximately the same percentage of test items (and behavioral objectives) are written at the level of recall, knowledge, or fact (Tombari & Borich, 1999). Therefore, test items, behavioral objectives, and most instruction seem to emphasize readily known facts as they are presented in curriculum guides, workbooks, and texts. The art of questioning will become one of your most important skills as a teacher. The variety you convey to your students will be determined in large measure by your flexible use of questions. Questions are rarely ends the themselves but rather a means of engaging students in the learning process by getting them to action, work through, or think about the material presented. Process Questions. From the previous discussion, you can see why not all questions should be content questions. There are different purposes for which questions can be asked, with the intent of encouraging different mental processes. To problem solve, to guide, to arouse curiosity, to encourage creativity, to analyze, to synthesize, and to judge also are goals of instruction that should be reflected in your questioning strategies. For these goals, content is not an end itself but a means of achieving higher-order goals. Researchers have used various terms to describe process questions. Such as the following: Types of Process Questions • Indirect: The question has various possible interpretations and alternative meanings. Example: “What are some of the ways you have used the word ancient?” • Higher-order: The question requires more complex mental processes than simple recall of facts (e.g., making generalizations and inferences). Example: “What were the effects of the cotton gin on attitudes in the North?” • Divergent: Different data sources will lead to different correct answers. Example: “From what we know about the many forms of pollution today, what would be one of the first things we have to do to clean the air we breathe?” • Open: A single correct answer is not expected possible. Example: “How have recent advances in computer technology influenced your life?” • Concept: The question requires the processes of abstraction, generalization, and inference. Example: Using examples of your own choosing, can you tell us some of the ways division and subtraction are similar?” Can you see the difference between this set of process questions and the list of content questions that preceded it? Notice that the process questions encourage more thinking and problem solving by requiring the learner to use personal sources of knowledge to actively construct her or his own interpretations and meanings rather than acquiring understanding by giving back knowledge already organized in the form in which it was told. As we saw earlier, this view of teaching and learning represents a movement in education called constructivism. Constructivist teaching strategies emphasize the learner’s direct experience and the dialogue of the classroom as instructional tools while deemphasizing lecturing and telling (Steffe & Gale, 1995). Process questions and the use of probes, our next helping behavior, are important aids in constructivist thinking and action in the classroom. We will have more to say about the role of direct experience and the use of constructivist strategies in the classroom in many of the chapters ahead, and especially in Chapters 6 and 8. Probing Another helping behavior is probing. Probing refers to teacher statements that encourage students to elaborate on an answer, either their own or another student’s. Probing may take the form of a general question or can include other expressions that elicit clarification of an answer, solicit additional information about a response, or redirect a student’s response in a more fruitful direction (Gage, 1976). Probing often is used to shift a discussion to some higher thought level. Generally, student achievement is greatest when the eliciting, soliciting, and (if necessary) redirecting occur in cycles. This systematically leads the discussion to a higher level of complexity, as when interrelationships, generalizations, and problem solutions are being sought (J. Dillon, 1995). In this manner, you may begin a lesson with a simple fact question; then, by eliciting clarification of student responses, soliciting new information, or redirecting an answer, you can move to a higher level of questioning. Notice that all of the ingredients in this teacher’s lesson were provided by the class. The concepts of hypothesis, experiment, and generalization were never defined for the class. The students defined this concepts for themselves with only an occasional “OK” or “Good” to the let them know they were on track. The teacher’s role was limited to eliciting clarification, soliciting additional information and redirection. The purpose of this cycle of eliciting, soliciting and redirection is to promote inquiry or independent discovery of the content of the lesson. Generally, retention of material learned has been greater from inquiry teaching than from formal lecturing methods (Paul, 1990). Teacher Affect Anyone who has ever been in a classroom where the teacher’s presentation was life-less, static, and without vocal variety can appreciate the commonsense value of affective behavior. However, unlike the behaviors discussed previously, affect cannot be captured in transcripts of teaching behavior or by classroom interaction instruments. Consequently, narrowly focused research instruments often miss a teacher’s affective behavior, which may be apparent from a more holistic view of the classroom. What the instruments miss, the students see clearly. Students are good perceivers of the emotions underlying a teacher’s actions, and they often respond accordingly. A teacher who is excited about the subject being taught and shows it by facial expression, voice inflection, gesture and general movement is more likely to hold the attention of students than one who does not exhibit these behaviors. This is true whether or not teachers consciously perceive these behaviors in themselves. Students take their cues from such behavioral signs and lower or heighten their engagement with the lesson accordingly. Enthusiasm is an important aspect of a teacher’s affect. Enthusiasm is the teacher’s vigor, power, involvement, excitement, and interest during a classroom presentation. We all know that enthusiasm is contagious, but how is it so? Enthusiasm is conveyed to students in many ways, the most common being vocal inflection, gesture, eye contact, and animation. A teacher’s enthusiasm was found to be related to student achievement (Bettencourt, Gilbert, Gall, & Hull, 1983; Cabello & Terrell, 1994). It also believed to be important in promoting student engagement in the learning process. Obviously, no one can maintain a heightened state of enthusiasm for very long without becoming exhausted emotionally. Nor is this what is meant by enthusiasm. A proper level of enthusiasm is far more subtle, and perhaps that is why it has been so difficult to research. A proper level of enthusiasm involves a delicate balance of vocal inflection, gesturing, eye contact, and movement. It employs each of these behaviors in only moderate ways. In combination, these behaviors send to students a unified signal of vigor, involvement, and interest. It is the use of these behaviors in moderation and at the right times that conveys the desired message. Timing and the ability to incorporate these behaviors into a consistent pattern make possible an unspoken behavioral dialogue with students that is every bit as important as your spoken words. Letting students know that you are ready to help by your warm and encouraging attitude is essential if your enthusiasm is to be taken as an honest and sincere expression of your true feelings. THE COMPLEXITY OF TEACHING The complexity and difficulty of learning to each arise from the complexity of the varied decision-making contexts in which teaching must occur. Herein lies one of the major problems with earlier attempts to define effective teaching by describing ideals types or by describing a teacher’s personality, attitude, experience, achievement, and aptitude. These attempts failed to consider that different teaching contexts require different teaching behaviors. Any single definition of effective teaching would be simplistic and inaccurate because of this insensitivity to the different learners, curricula, grade levels, and instructional materials with which teaching and learning must take place. It is the proper mix of key and helping behaviors in the context of your classroom that will come to define effective teaching for you. In the chapters ahead you will learn how to vary this mix accordingly, giving each key and helping behavior its proper emphasis within your grade, subject, learners, and curriculum. Now let’s turn to the importance or certain behaviors in several different teaching contexts. TEACHING EFFECTIVELY WITH DIVERSE LEARNERS AND CONTENT Researchers have uncovered behaviors of special importance to specific types of students and content. Two areas of finding having the most consistent results are: 1. Teaching behaviors that positively affect learners of lower and higher socioeconomic status 2. Teaching behaviors that impact reading and mathematics How Does Effective Teaching Differ When Learners Have a Variety of Socioeconomic Levels, Culture, and Ethnicity? The phrase socioeconomic status (SES) can mean many different things generally it is an approximate index of one’s income and education level. For the classroom researcher, the SES of students is determined directly by the income and education of their parents, or indirectly by the nature of the school the student attends. Some schools are in impoverished areas where the overall income and education levels of the community are low, whereas other schools are located in more affluent communities. Many schools in impoverished areas quality for special financial assistance from the federal government, based on the median income of their students’ parents. Researchers consider these “Chapter 1” schools to be those where the majority of students come from lower-SES homes and may be disadvantaged, and/or are “at risk” of school failure. Because lower-SES and higher-SES students and schools are facts of life that are likely to exist for some time, classroom researchers have determined what teacher behaviors promote the most achievement in these two types of students. Bowers & Flinders (1991), Good & Brophy (1997), Hill (1989), and Kennedy (1991) provide suggestions for teaching these two student populations. Some important teaching behaviors to emphasize for these two groups are summarized in Table 1.8. Notice in the table that, while each behavior is applicable to both lower and higher-SES students, teacher effect is particularly important in lower-SES classroom. Also, notice that some of these teaching behaviors received little or no mention in our preceding discussions, because those discussions applied to students generally. Four of the behaviors shown for lower-SES classrooms (student responses, over teaching/over learning, classroom interaction, and individualization) can be seen as special ways of creating student engagement at high rates of success. This presents a particular challenge when teaching lower-SES students who may be at risk for school failure. Also, frequently correcting wrong answers in the absence of support or encouragement could be construed as a personal criticism by some lower-SES students, who already may have a poor self-concept. Therefore, feedback that could be construed as criticism may need to occur in the context of a more supportive and encouraging environment than may be needed for the higher-SES learner (Cabello & Terrell, 1994). Because much of the research on SES has been conducted in elementary classrooms, it is as yet uncertain to what extent these teaching behaviors apply to the secondary classroom. However, many of the learning characteristics of higher-SES and lower-SES students appear to be similar across these school contexts. Therefore, your success as a teacher in a predominantly lower-SES classroom may depend on your ability to vary the extent to which you emphasize the behaviors in Table 1.8. How Does Effective Teaching Differ Across Content Areas? Another set of findings pertains to the different teaching behaviors that distinguish reading from mathematics instruction (Brophy & Evertson, 1976a; Good & Grouws, 1979; Reynolds, 1989). Although not all teachers will teach either reading or mathematics, this set of findings may be generalized to some extent to other types of content that are similar in form of structure. For example, social studies, history and language instruction all have high reading content and share some of the same problem-solving features as reading. General science, biology, physics, and chemistry are similar to the science of mathematics in that concepts, principles, and laws all play a prominent roles. Also, visual forms and symbolic expressions are at least as important to understanding science subjects as is the written word. Therefore, some cautious generalizations may be made about the teaching behaviors important for reading and basic mathematics instruction and for subjects similar to each. Some important findings are summarized in Table 1.9. Notice the two different approaches implied by the behaviors listed. For basic mathematics instruction a formal direct approach appear to be most effective. This approach includes maintaining structure through close adherence to texts, workbooks, and application-oriented activities. It also maximizes instructional coverage by minimizing unstructured work that could diminish engaged learning time. On the other hand, reading instruction allows for a more interactive and indirect approach, using more classroom discussions and experience-oriented questions and answers. These approaches, however, are not mutually exclusive. What the research shows is that, in general and over time, a more direct approach during basic mathematics instruction tends to result in greater student progress than would say the exclusive use of an inquiry approach. For reading, the reverse appears to be true an exploratory, interactive approach that encourages the use of classroom dialogue and student ideas tends to result in greater student progress over time. These different approaches represent degrees of emphasis and not exclusive strategies. Clearly, teaching the basics of mathematics will at times require an inquiry approach, just as reading sometimes requires a lecture or telling approach. More important than either of these approaches or the behaviors that represent them is the ability of the teacher to be flexible. The effective teacher senses when a change from one emphasis to another is necessary, regardless of the content being taught. REVIEW OF SOME IMPORTANT TEACHER EFFECTIVENESS INDICATORS If this chapter were reduced to simple advice to improve your teaching, the result would be a simplistic definition of an effective teacher. However, if you ask for some indicators of teaching effectiveness that have demonstrated importance in improving student achievement, the following list will help. These are some of the general indicators of effective teaching that are currently supported by the research literature. The following chapters use the indicators to introduce specific instructional practices that will help you create these same behaviors in your own classroom. The effective teacher: • Takes personal responsibility for student’s learning and has positive expectations for every learner. • Matches the difficulty of the lesson with the ability level of the student and varies the difficulty when necessary to attain moderate-to-high success. • Give students the opportunity to practice newly learned concepts and to receive timely feedback on their performance. • Maximizes instructional time to increase content coverage and to give students the greatest opportunity to learn. • Provides direction and control of student learning through questioning, structuring, and probing. • Uses a variety of instructional materials and verbal and visual aids to foster use of student ideas and engagement in the learning. • Elicits responses from students each time a question is asked before moving to the next student or question. • Presents material in small steps with opportunities for practice. • Encourages students to reason out and elaborate on the correct answer. • Engages students in verbal questions and answer. • Uses naturally occurring classroom dialogue to get students to elaborate, extend, and comment on the content being learned. • Gradually shifts some of the responsibility for learning to the students-encouraging independent thinking, problem solving, and decision making. • Provides learners with mental strategies for organizing and learning the content being taught. At this point, you might think that an effective teacher simply is one who has mastered all of the key behaviors and helping behaviors. But teaching involves more than a knowledge of how to perform individual behaviors. Much like an artist who blends color and texture into a painting to produce a coherent impression, so must the effective teacher blend individual behaviors to different degrees to promote student achievement. This requires orchestration and integration of the key and helping behaviors into meaningful patterns and rhythms that can achieve to goals of instruction within your classroom. The truly effective teacher knows how to execute individual behaviors with a larger purpose in mind. This larger purpose requires placing behaviors side by side in ways that accumulate to create an effect greater than can be achieved by any single behavior or small set of them. This is why teaching involves a sense of timing, sequencing, and pacing that cannot be conveyed by any list of behaviors. The interrelationships among these behaviors, giving each its proper emphasis in the context of your classroom, are so important to the effective teacher. And it is the combination of curriculum, learning objectives, instructional materials, and learners that provides the decision-making context for the proper connection. YOUR TRANSITION TO THE REAL WORLD OF TEACHING An important question for you as a prospective teacher is what type of knowledge and experiences will be needed to pass successfully into the real world of teaching. The chapters ahead will convey the types of knowledge you will need to move quickly up hierarchy of knowledge and experiences that make an effective teacher. But, before learning about the tools and techniques that will help you progress up this hierarchy, you will want to determine your own concerns about teaching at this point in your career. Appendix a contains the Teacher Concerns Checklist, a 45-item self-report instrument for assessing the stages of concern with which a teacher most strongly identifies. Using the Teacher Concerns Checklist, rank your own level of teaching concerns, and with the instructions provided, determine the concerns with which you identify most closely. Then return to this chapter and read further to learn more about this interesting facet of your growth and developments as a teacher. Stop now and complete the Teacher Concerns Checklist in Appendix A. Now that you’ve ranked your most important teaching concerns, let’s see what a means for your teaching. Your transition to the real world of teaching will user in the first stage of teacher development, sometimes called the survival stage (Borich, 1993; Burden, 1986; Fuller, 1969; Ryan, 1992). This distinguishing feature of this first stage of teaching is that your teaching concerns and plans will focus on your own well-being more than on the teaching task or your learners. Bullough (1989) has described this stage as “the fight for one’s professional life” (p. 16). During it, your concerns typically are focused on the following: • Will my learners like me? • Will they listen to what I say? • What will parents and other teachers think of me? • Will I do well when I’m being observed? Typically, during this time, behavior management concerns becoming a major focus of your planning efforts. For most teachers, survival-or self-concerns-begin to diminish rapidly during the first months of teaching, but there is no precise time when they end. What signal their end is transition to a new set of concerns and planning priorities. This new set of priorities focuses on how best to deliver instruction. Various labels have been used to describe this second stage, such as the mastery stage of teaching (Ryan, 1992), consolidation and exploration (Burden, 1986), and trial and error (Sacks & Harrington, 1982). Fuller (1969) described this stage as one marked by concerns about the teaching task. At this stage you are beginning to feel confident that you can manage the day-to-day routines of the classroom and deal with a variety of behaviors problems. You are at the point where you now can plan your lessons without an exclusive focus on managing your classroom. Your planning turns instead toward improving your teaching skills and achieving greater mastery over the content you are teaching. Typically, your concerns during this stage are with the following: • Where can I find good instructional materials? • Will I have enough time to cover the content? • Where can I get ideas for a learning center? • What’s the best way to each writing skills? The third and highest level of teacher planning is characterized by concerns that have less to do with management and lesson delivery and more the impact of your teaching on learners. This stage of planning is sometimes referred to as the impact stage. At this stage you will naturally view learners as individuals and will be concerned that each of your students fulfills her or his potential to learn. At this time, your principal concerns will be the following: • How can I increase my learners’ feelings of accomplishment? • How do I meet my learners’ social and emotional needs? • What is the best way to challenge my unmotivated learners? • What skills do they need to best prepare them for the next grade? Fuller (1969) speculated that concerns for self, task and impact are the natural stages that most teachers pass through, representing, a developmental growth pattern extending over months and even years of a teacher’s career. Although some teachers may pass through these stages more quickly than others and different levels of intensity, Fuller suggested that almost all teachers can be expected to move from one to another, with the most effective and experienced teachers expressing student-centered (impact) concerns at a high level of commitment. Fuller’s concerns theory has several other interesting implications. A teacher might return to an earlier stage of concern-move from a concern for students back to a concern for task as a result of having to each a new grade or subject, or move from a concern for task back to concern for self as a result of having to teach different and unfamiliar students. The second time spent in a stage might be expected to be shorter than the first. Finally, the three stages of concern need not be exclusive of one another. A teacher could have concerns predominately in one area while still having concerns at lesser levels of intensity in the other stages. Record your scores on the Teacher Concerns Checklist that you have just taken, and compare them with your scores at the end of this course to find out in what direction your concerns may have changed. CHAPTER 2 UNDERSTANDING YOUR SYUDENTS WHY PAY ATTENTION TO INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES? Any observer in any classroom quickly notices that schoolchildren vary in their experiences, socioeconomic statue (SES), culture, language, and learning style. Differences experience, SES, culture, language, and learning style influence what students learn (Banks, 1997; Dunn & Griggs, 1995). Of what consequence is such as obvious observation? After all, you must teach all the students assigned to you, regardless of their differences. Two of the reasons for being aware of individual differences among learners in your classroom follow: 1. By recognizing individual differences, you can help your learners use their own experiences and learning histories to the derive meaning and understanding from what you are teaching. With that knowledge, you will be better able to adapt your instructional methods to the individual learning needs of your students. 2. When counseling students and talking with parents about the achievement and behavior of your learners, you will be able to convey some of reasons for what you are describing. Understanding your students’ individual differences can provide perspective for parents, counselors, and other way Jared is not learning, why Anita learns without studying, or why Angela doesn’t want to learn? Researchers are discovering many content areas and individual differences for which adapting different instructional strategies to the strengths of learners has significantly improved their performance (Corno &Snow, 1986; Cronbach & Snow, 1977). For example, student-centered discussion have significantly improved the achievement of highly anxious students by providing a more informal, nurturing climate, while teacher-centered lectures have benefited the achievement of low-anxiety students by allowing for a more efficient (Dowaliby & Schumer, 1973). The linguistic approach to the teaching of reading has resulted in higher vocabulary achievement for students high in auditory ability and who learn best by hearing, while the whole-word approach was more effective for students low in auditory ability and who learn best by seeing (Stallings & Keepers, 1970). Researchers have found that achievement can be increased when the instructional method favors the learners’ natural modalities for learning (Cushner, McCelland & Safford, 1992; Messick, 1995). Adaptive Teaching The general approach to achieving a common instructional goal with learners whose individual differences, such as prior achievement, aptitude, or learning styles, differ widely is called adaptive teaching. Adaptive teaching techniques apply different instructional strategies to different groups of learners so that the natural diversity prevailing in the classroom does not prevent any learner from achieving success. Two approaches to adaptive teaching have been reported to be effective (Corno & Snow, 1986). They are the remediation approach and the compensatory approach. The Remediation Approach. The remediation approach provides the learner with the prerequisite knowledge, skill, or behavior needed to benefit from the planned instruction. For example, you might attempt to lower the anxiety of highly anxious student with a student-centered discussion before an important lecture, so that the lecture method could equally benefit all students. Or, you might teach listening skills to students low in auditory ability before using a linguistic approach to reading so that both groups could profit equally from the linguistic approach. The remediation approach to adaptive teaching will be successful to the extent that the desired information, skill, or behavior can be taught within a reasonable period of time. When this is not possible or represents an inefficient use of classroom time, the compensatory approach to adaptive teaching can be taken. The Compensatory Approach. Using the compensatory approach, teachers choose an instructional method to circumvent or compensate for the lack of information, skills, or ability known to exist among learners. With this approach to adaptive teaching, teachers alter content presentation to circumvent a weakness and promote a strength. This is done by using alternate modalities (e.g., pictures vs. words) or by supplementing content with additional learning resources (games and simulations) and activities (group discussions, hands-on experiences). This may involve modifying the instructional technique to compensate for known deficiencies and to use known strengths. Techniques include the visual representation of content, using more flexible instructional presentations (films, pictures, illustrations) shifting to alternate instructional formats (self-paced texts, simulations, experience-oriented workbooks), or using authentic, performance-based assessment procedures that might require students to assemble a portfolio of their experiences, ideas, and products pertaining to a topic. For example, students who are poor at reading comprehension and lack a technical math vocabulary might be taught a geometry unit supplemented with visual handouts. Portraying each theorem and axiom graphically emphasizes the visual modality. Other students having an adequate reading comprehension and vocabulary level might learn the same theorems and axioms exclusively from the text, thereby emphasizing verbal learning. Benefits of Adaptive Teaching. Notice the adaptive teaching goes beyond the simpler process of ability grouping, in which learners are divided into groups and then presented approximately the same material at different rates. Some research suggests that differences in academic performance between high and low achievers may actually increase with the use of ability grouping, creating a loss of self-esteem and motivation for the low group (Good & Stipek, 1983; Kerchoff, 1986; Slavin, 1991a). Adaptive teaching, on the other hand, works to achieve success with all students, regardless of their individual differences. It does so either by remediation (building up the knowledge, skills, or abilities required to profit from planned instruction) or by compensation (circumventing weakness by avoiding instructional methods/materials that rely on abilities that may be less well developed). Therefore, adaptive teaching requires an understanding of your students learning abilities and the alternative instructional methods that can maximize their strongest receptive modalities (e.g., visual vs.). The chapters ahead provide a menu of such strategies from which to choose. Some of the most promising instructional alternatives in adaptive teaching include the following: • Cooperative grouping versus whose class instruction • Inductive versus expository presentation • Rule-example versus example-rule ordering • Inductive versus deductive presentation • Teacher-centered versus student-centered presentation • Direct versus indirect instruction • Examples from experience versus examples from text • Group phonics versus individualized phonics instruction • Individual responses versus choral responses • Subvocal responses versus vocal responses • Self-regulated versus whole-group instruction • Programmed versus conventional instruction Each of these teaching methods or presentation style has been found more effective for some types of learners than for others (Cronbach & Snow, 1977; Rohrkemper & Corno, 1988). The research literature and curriculum texts in your teaching area offer many examples of specific content areas in which a particular instructional method-in association with a particular student characteristic-has enhanced student performance. However, common sense and classroom experience will suggest many other ways in which you can alter teaching to fit the individual needs of your students. By knowing your students and having a variety of instructional methods available, you can adjust your instruction to the learning needs of your students with one of these two methods of adaptive teaching. THE EFFETCS OF GENERAL INTELLIGENCE ON LEARNING One thing everyone remembers about elementary school is how some students seemed to learn so easily, while others had to work so hard. In high school the range of student ability seemed even greater. In practical sense, we associate the terms smart, bright, ability to solve problems, learn quickly, and figure things out with intelligence. Both in the classroom and in life, it seems that some have more abilities than others. The observation often has been a source of anxiety, concern, and jealousy among learners. Perhaps because the topic of intelligence can so easily elicit emotions like these, it is one of the most talked about and one of the least understood aspects of student behavior. One of the greatest misunderstandings that some teachers, parents, and learners have about intelligence is that it is single, unified dimension. Such a belief is often expressed by the use of word pairs such as slow/fast and bright/dull when referring to different kinds of learners. Unfortunately, these phrases indicate that a student is either fast or slow, either bright or dull; in fact, each of us, regardless of our intelligence, may be all of these at one time or another. On a particular task of certain nature, you may appear to be slow, but given another task requiring different abilities, you may be fast. How do such vast differences occur within a single individual? Everyone knows from personal experience in school, hobbies, sports, and interpersonal relationships that degree of intelligence depends on the circumstances and conditions under which the intelligence is exhibited. Observations such as these have led researchers to study and identify more than one kind of intelligence. This relatively new way of looking intelligence has led to a better understanding of classic contradictions like why Carlos is good in vocabulary but not in spelling, why Angela is good in social studies but poor at reading maps, or why Tamara is good at analyzing the reason behind historical events but not at memorizing the names and dates that go along with them. Each of these seemingly contradictory behaviors can be explained by the special abilities required by each task. These specific abilities, in which we all differ, are the most useful aspects of intelligence for understanding the learning behavior of your students. Before turning to these specific abilities, you should be aware of some controversial issues about the use of general intelligence when discussing intelligence with parents, teachers, and school administrators. These issues often strongly divide individuals into two camps, known as the environmentalist position and the hereditarian position. The Environmentalist Position The environmentalist position criticizes the use of general IQ tests in the schools in the belief that they are culturally biased. Environmentalist believe that differences in IQ scores among groups such as African, Americans, Hispanics, and Anglos can be attributed largely to social class or environmental differences. Environmentalist reason that some groups of students, particularly minorities, may come from impoverished home environments in which the verbal skills generally required to do well on intelligence tests are not practiced. Therefore, significant part of minority-student scores on any IQ test represents the environment in which they grew up and not their true intelligence. Environmentalists conclude and some research supports that effect of home environment is at least as important as heredity in contributing to one’s IQ (Bloom, 1981; Smilansky, 1979). This group believes that intelligence tests are biased in favor of the white middle class, who, it is believed, are able to provide their children with more intense patterns of verbal interaction, greater reinforcement for learning, more learning resources, and better physical health during the critical preschool years when cognitive growth is fastest. The Hereditarian Position The hereditarian position concludes that heredity rather than environment is the major factor determining intelligence. Hereditarians base their beliefs on the research and writings of Arthur Jensen (1969). They believe that not all children have the some potential for developing the same mental abilities. They contend that efforts such as compensatory education programs to make up for environment disadvantages the early elementary grades through remediation have limited success because the origin of the difference is genetic and not environmental (Herrastein & Murray, 1994). General Versus Specific Intelligence Common sense tells us these is some truth in both arguments. However, despite how parents, other teachers, and even your own students may feel, these positions are highly dependent on the notion of general intelligence. The arguments become less relevant in the context of specific abilities. General intelligence only moderately predicts school grades, whereas specific abilities tend to predict not only school grades but also more important real-life behaviors that school grades are supposed to represent (Tombari & Borich, 1999). For example, taests of general intelligence cannot predict success as a salesperson, factory worker, carpenter, computer programmer, or teacher, because they measure few of the specific abilities required for success in these occupations. If we think of school learning as a pie and IQ as a piece of it, we can ask the question: How large a piece of the classroom learning pie is taken up by IQ? Another way of asking this name question is: What percentage of school learning can be attributed to IQ and what percentage to other factors? Scarr (1981) indicates that many factors, in addition in IQ, will contribute to your learners’ success: their motivation, support from parents, prior knowledge, health, use of learning strategies, emotional stability, and the quality of your teaching to name only some. Scarr classifies these factors under the term social competence. What percentage of school learning can be assigned to IQ and what percentage to all the other factors, Scarr’s social competence? The answer, illustrated in figure 2.1, is that only about 25% can be attributed to IQ; about 75% must be assigned to social competence. So, knowing your learners’ specific strengths and altering your instructional goals and activities accordingly will contribute far more to your effective teaching than will categorizing your students’ performances in ways that indicate only their general intelligence. THE EFFECTS OF SPECIFIC ABILITIES ON LEARNING Specific definitions of intelligence and the behaviors they represent commonly are called aptitudes. As a teacher, you are unlikely to measure aptitudes in your classroom, but you need to know of their influence on the performance of your students. Your students may already have been aptitude-tested in a direct-wide testing program or you can ask the school counselor or psychologist to measure a specific aptitude to find the source of a specific learning problem. Your acquaintance with the division of general intelligence into specific aptitudes will help you see how a learner’s abilities in specific areas can directly affect the degree of learning that takes place. Multiple Intelligences Some of the many specialized abilities that have been reliably measured include verbal comprehension, general reasoning, memory, use of numbers, psychomotor speed, spatial relations, and word fluency. This list of abilities resulted from the work of L. L. Thurstone (1947). Instead of reinforcing the idea of a single IQ score. Thurstone’s work led to the development of seven different IQs, each measured by a separate test. In this manner the concept of general intelligence was divided into component parts, it had the obvious advantage that a specific score for a given part could be related to certain types of learning requirements. Some learning activities require a high degree of memory, such as memorizing long list of words in preparation for a spelling bee or a vocabulary test. Likewise, spatial relations, use of numbers, and general reasoning ability are essential for high levels of performance in mathematics. Such differences in aptitude are more useful than general intelligence in explaining to parents why Alexis can get excellent scores on math tests that emphasize number problems (12 + 2 x 6 =) but poor scores on math tests that emphasize word problems (If Bob rows 4 mph against a current flowing 2 mph, how long will it take him to row 16 miles?) Such apparent contradictions become more understandable in the light of specific aptitudes. Thurstone’s (1947) dimensions were among the earliest, and other components of intelligence have been hypothesized. For example, H. Gardner and Hatch (1989) proposed eight different intelligences based on skills found in modern technological society. The eight abilities identified by Gardner and Hatch, some representative individuals who would be expected to possess high levels of these abilities, and the things those individuals would be good at are identified in Table 2.1. Campbell, Campbell and Dickinson (1996) and Lazear (1992) have developed instructional materials and modules to teach some of these abilities. The materials and methods developed by Campbell et al (1996) and Lazear (1992) derive from the observation that many individuals who are successful in life do not score high in traditional indicators of ability, such as verbal or mathematical reasoning. Gardner and his associates (Gardner & Hatch, 1989) suggest that these individuals, to be successful, used other abilities, such as those in Table 2.1, to minimize their weaknesses in some areas and emphasize their strengths in others. Their theory may have particular relevance for teaching at-risk learners, some of whom may not learn from school in the traditional classroom setting using the traditional curriculum. These researchers reason that alternative forms of learning could tap into other dimensions of intelligence that in the traditional classroom may go unnoticed or underutilized. Have content area specialists identified still other specific forms of intelligence nestled within those suggested by Thurstone (1917) and by Gardner and Hatch (1989). For example, content specialists in reading have identified no fewer than nine verbal comprehension factors, which indicate the ability to do the following: • Know word meanings • See contextual meaning • See organization • Follow thought patterns • Find specifics • Express ideas • Draw inferences • Identify literary devices • Determine a writer’s purpose In other words, a learner’s general performance in reading may be affected by any one or a combination of these specific abilities. This and similar lists point up an interesting and sometimes controversial aspect of intelligence: once abilities such as draw inferences, follow thought patterns, and find contextual meaning are defined, is it possible to teach these so-called components of intelligence? Hereditarians say that intelligence is not teachable, but it seems logical that, with proper instruction, a learner could be taught to draw inferences, follow thought patterns, and find contextual meaning. As general components of intelligence, such as those defined by Thurstone (1947) and by Gardner and Hatch (1989) become divided into smaller and more specific aptitudes, the general concept of intelligence has become demystified. At least some elements of intelligence depend on achievement in certain areas that can be influenced by instruction. Therefore, another advantage of the multidimensional approach to intelligence is that some specific abilities once thought to be unalterable can be taught. Sternberg’s Theory of Intelligence One of the most recent conceptions of specialized abilities comes from Sternberg (1994, 1995). Sternberg’s work has been important in forming new definitions of intelligence that allow for intellectual traits, previously believed to be inherited and unalterable, to be improved through instruction. Further, Sternberg suggest not only that intelligence can be taught but also that the classroom is the logical place to teach it. Let’s look more closely at the theory from which this claim is made. Sternberg’s theory of intelligence is called triarcbic because it consists of three parts: (1) the individual’s internal world, (2) how the individual acquires intelligence, and (3) the individual’s external world. The Individual’s Internal World. The first part of Sternberg’s (1994, 1995) theory relates to the individual’s internal world that governs thinking. Three kinds of mental process occur, instrumental in planning (1) what things to do, (2) how to learn to do them, and (3) how to actually perform them. The first of these processes is used in planning, monitoring, and evaluating the performance of a task. In essence, this is an executive component that tells all other components of our intelligence what to do, like the boss who gives directions but who does none of the work. Hence, this component’s role is purely administrative. A second component of this internal world of intelligence governs behavior in actual task performance. This component controls the various strategies used in solving problems. For example, one strategy is to guide you to the most relevant details of a problem and steer you away from the irrelevant. Thus, individuals can become more or less intelligent by learning which details need attention and which to ignore. A third component of this internal world of intelligence governs what previously acquired knowledge we bring to a problem. It is here that Sternberg’s (1994, 1995) theory differs most from other concepts of intelligence. In his view, the innate and less alterable characteristics of memory, manipulating symbols, or mental speed are not particularly important to intelligence. Instead, he sees the previously acquired knowledge that one brings to problem solving as more important to thinking intelligently. How the Individual Acquires Intelligence. Sternberg (1994, 1995) proposes that intelligence is the ability to learn and to think using previously discovered patterns and relationships to solve new problems in unfamiliar contexts. By experiencing many novel tasks and conditions early in life, we discover the patterns and relationships that tell us how to solve new problems with which we may be totally unfamiliar. In other words, the greater our experience in facing unique and novel conditions, the more we grow and can adapt to the changing conditions around us. Sternberg suggests that confronting novel tasks and situations and learning to deal with them is one of the most important instructional goals in learning intelligence behavior. His writings provide many practical exercises and examples of how to become facile at learning to deal with novel tasks and situations that provide the patterns and relationships with which to enhance our intelligence. The Individual’s External World. The third part of Sternberg’s theory relates intelligence to the external world of the individual. This is where an individual’s intelligence shows most can be altered quickest. This part of intelligence is governed by how well one learns to adapt to the environment (change his or her way doing things to fit the world), to select from the environment (avoid unfamiliar things and choose familiar and comfortable ones). Thus, intelligent people learn to adapt, select and shape their environment better and faster than do less intelligent people. Therefore, perhaps the most important aspect of Sternberg’s theory is that intelligence results as much from how people learn to cope with the world around them as it from the internal mental processes with which they are born (e.g., memory, symbol manipulation, mental speed). This notion of coping is expressed by 20 characteristics that Sternberg (1994, 1995) suggests often impede intelligent behavior and, therefore, are often found in the unintelligent or the non expert: • Lack of motivation • Lack of impulse control • Lack of perseverance • Using the wrong abilities • Inability to translate thought into action • Lack of the product orientation • Inability to complete tasks and to follow through • Failure to initiate • Fear of failure • Procrastination • Misattribution of blame • Excessive self-pity • Excessive dependency • Wallowing in personal difficulties • Distractibility and lack of concentration • Spreading oneself to him • Inability to delay gratification • Inability or unwillingness to see the forest for the trees • Lack of balance between critical thinking and creative thinking • Too little or too much self-confidence According to Sternberg (1994, 1995), many aspects to intelligence can and should be taught and the classroom is the logical place to convey the attitudes and behaviors that can help learners avoid these impediments to intelligent behavior. THE EFFECTS OF PRIOR ACHIEVEMENT ON LEARNING Closely related to Sternberg’s (1994, 1995) notion of intelligence are the prior knowledge and skills of your learners-specifically, their task-relevant knowledge and skills. Task relevant means those facts, skills, and understandings that must be taught if subsequent learning is to occur. Mastery of these behaviors makes possible future learning. Thus, their identification is important not only in planning instruction but also in accounting for why learning does not occur in some situations and for some students. These task-relevant facts, skills, and understandings come in various shapes and sizes. In each content area, they are part of the logical progression of ideas with which a lesson is conveyed. For example, various orders of reasoning may be used-general-to-detailed, simple-to-complex, abstract-to-concrete, or conceptual-to-procedural. These logical progressions are learning structures that identity at each step those behaviors needed before new learning can take place (e.g., procedures must come before concepts, and simple facts must come before complex details). Many task-relevant prior learning are embedded within these progressions. It is on these progressions that the final outcomes of a lesson or unit depend. This point is illustrated in Figure 2.2 for an instructional unit on government and Figure 2.3 for a unit on writing skills. Notice that in Figure 2.2, the concepts of presidential and parliamentary would have to be learned before the concept of a representative democracy could be understood. And, the concepts of monarchy, oligarchy, and democracy would have to be learned before attaining an understanding. These task-relevant prior achievements provide a structure for learning that allows larger concepts, principles, and generalizations to be learned at the end of a lesson or unit. Notice that a breakdown in the flow of learning at almost any level would prevent learning from taking place at any subsequent level. Failure to attain concepts at higher levels in the instructional may not indicate a lack of ability but a failure to adequately attain task-relevant prior behaviors. THE EFFECTSS OF HOME AND FAMILY ON LEARNING It is well known that a relationship exists between social class and educational achievement. Traditionally, students from lower-class and lower middle-class families have not performed as well on standardized achievement tests as have students from middle-class and upper-class families. Researchers have studied the relationship among social class, race/ethnicity, and school achievement (Mansnerus, 1992; Sleeter & Grant, 1991). Their studies generally conclude that most differences in educational achievement occurring among racial and ethnic groups can be by social class, even after the lower SES of minority groups is considered (Gamoran, 1992; Levine & Havinghuast, 1984). In other words, if you know the SES of a group of students, you can predict their achievement with some accuracy. Information about their racial and ethnic group does little to improve the prediction. This indicates the powerful effect social class can have on the behavior of your student. Why SES is Important in Learning It is now appropriate to ask “What is about SES that creates differences in the classroom?” and “What can I, a teacher, do to lessen these differences?” Obviously, if SES plays a role in student achievement, it must stand for something more specific than income and the educational level of parents. Research shows that a number of more meaningful characteristics in which the home and family lives of higher and lower-SES families differ are associated with income and education-are thought to influence the achievement of schoolchildren. One characteristic that seems to distinguish children of the lower class from those in the middle and upper socioeconomic class is that the letter are more likely to acquire knowledge of the world outside their home and neighborhood at an earlier age (Delgado-Gaitan, 1991). Through greater access to books, magazines, social networks, cultural events, and others who have these learning resources, middle-and upper-class students develop their reading and speaking abilities more rapidly. This, in combination with parental teaching (which tends to use the formal or elaborated language that trains the child to think independently of the specific communication context), may give students in the middle and upper classes an advantage at the start of school. This contrasts with children who come from lower-class homes, which may emphasize obedience and conformity rather than independent thinking and may emphasize rote learning (memorization, recall of facts, etc.) rather than independent, self-directed learning (Christenson, Rounds, & Franklin, 1992; Grave, Weinstein, & Walberg, 1983; Leler, 1983) Contributing to these differences is the fact that 70% of working-age mothers of disadvantaged student must work. In the last 60 years, the composition of the family has undergone a dramatic change. The traditional family unit is no longer the rule, but the exception. As recently as 1965, more than 60% of American families were traditional: a working father and a mother who kept the house and took care of the children. Only 10% of today’s family is more likely to be a dual-career family, a single-parent family, a stepfamily, or a family that has moved an average of 14 times. All of these conditions affect the fabric of the family and the development of the school-age learners within it. By some estimates, the majority of children now being born will live in a house-hold where there is no adult 10 to 12 hours a day. Less time for parents to become involved in their child’s education, more distracting lifestyles, and greater job and occupational stress can be expected to contribute to the growing numbers of disadvantaged learners. H. Levin (1986) has estimated that educationally disadvantaged youth comprise more than one third of all school-age children. The Teacher’s Role in Improving Achievement Among Lower-SES Students The classroom is the logical place to begin the process of reducing some of the achievement differences that have been noted between lower-and middle/upper-SES students. Many formal interventions are trying to reduce the differences, from preschools to federally funded compensatory educations programs. However, these interventions and programs are not likely to eliminate achievement differences among various groups of students who have highly divergent home and family lifestyles’ This leaves you, the classroom teacher, to deal with these differences as a daily fact of life. The general tendencies are clean the home and family backgrounds of lower-and higher-SES students differentially prepare them for school. For the classroom teacher, the task becomes one of planning instruction around these differences in ways that reduce than as much as possible. There are several ways to make the achievement differences between social classes in your classroom more easily altered by your instructional methods. One of these is your willingness to incorporate a variety of learning aids (such as audiovisuals, learning centers, and exploratory materials) into your lessons. This variety of materials encourages your learners to use their own experiences, past learning, and preferred learning modalities in which to construct and demonstrate what they have learned. Thus, lesson variety can be an important resource for those who may benefit from alternative ways of learning. Another way in which to reduce achievement differences due to social class is to have high expectations for all your students and to reward them for their accomplishments. Sufficiently high expectations and rewards for learning outside the classroom may not be equally available to all of your learners. Your role in providing high expectations, support, and encouragement in the classroom could be instrumental in bridging some of the differences in achievement among your learners. Finally as an effective teacher, you should provide learners the opportunity to express their own sense of what they know and to build connections or relationships among the ideas and facts being taught using their own experiences. It is important to encourage learners to construct and express understandings and meanings of their own in a form that is most comfortable to them. This has two important effects in helping you attain the instructional goals of your classroom: it promotes student engagement and interest in your subject while showing them that someone thinks they have something worthwhile to say. Other ways you can reduce the differences among learners in your class include (Borich & Tombari, 1997, pp. 177-187) the following: 1. Organize learning and instruction around important ideas that your students already know something about. 2. Acknowledge the importance of your student’s prior learning by having them compare what they know with what you are teaching. 3. Challenge the adequacy of your student’s prior knowledge by designing lessons that create to opportunity for your students to resolve conflict and construct new meanings for themselves. 4. Provide some tasks that make students confront ambiguity and uncertainty by exploring problems that have multiple solutions in authentic, real-world contexts. 5. Teach students how to find their own approaches or systems for achieving educational goals. 6. Teach students that knowledge construction is a joint effort rather than a solitary search of knowledge or an exclusively teacher-controlled activity. 7. Assess a student’s knowledge acquisition, and provide feedback during the lesson. THE EFFECTS OF PERSONALITY ON LEARNING Preceding sections discussed the potential influence on learning of student’s general intelligence, specific aptitude, task-relevant prior achievement, and home life. In this section your students’ personalities will be added to this equation. When words such as trustworthy, creative, independent, anxious, cheerful, authoritarian, or aggressive are used to describe a student, they refer to an aspect of that student’s personality. Personality is the integration of one’s traits, motives, beliefs, and abilities, including emotional responses, character, and even values. The notion of personality is indeed broad and, according to some authors, even subsumes intelligence and specialized abilities. It is not necessary to take so broad a view of personality, because not every part of what is considered to be personality is applicable to classroom learning. On the other hand, several aspects of personality are so important to learning that learning probably could not occur without them. These aspects of personality are called traits. Traits are enduring aspects of a person’s behavior that are consistent across a variety of settings. Traits are not specific to subject matter content, grade level, or instructional objective, as are aptitude and achievement. However, this does not mean that variations in content, grade level, and objectives are unimportant to personality. In fact, many things within a classroom can trigger some personality traits and not others. Some parts of personalities lie dormant until stimulated to action by some particular perception of the world. This is the reason teachers often are dismayed to hear, for example, that an aggressive child in fifth-period social studies is shy and cooperative in someone else’s seventh-period mathematics. It also is the reason that some students and teachers may never quite see eye to eye. Fortunately, such personality conflicts are rare, but they can be harmful to classroom rapport if left to smolder beneath the surface. ERIKSON’S CRISES OF THE SCHOOL YEARS Some psychologists believe that different personality traits dominate at certain periods of our lives. For example, Erikson (1968), who developed a theory on how we form our personalities, hypothesized eight different stages of personality growth between infancy and old age that he called crises. Three of these stages, shown in Figure 2.4, occur during the school years: 1. The crisis of accomplishment versus inferiority 2. The crisis of identity versus role confusion 3. The crisis of intimacy versus isolation During the first crisis, on accomplishment versus inferiority, the student seeks ways of producing products or accomplishments that are respected by others. In this manner the child creates a feeling of worth to dispel feelings of inferiority or inadequacy that result from competing in a world where adults appear confident and competent. At first, such accomplishments may take the easiest course-being good at sports, being good in school, or being helpful at home. For the teacher this is a particularly challenging time, because student engagement at high rates of success is needed to keep some feelings of worth focused in the classroom. Seeing that every student has some successful experiences in the classroom can be an important vehicle for helping students through this crisis. Erikson’s second crisis during the school years is precipitated by the student’s need to understand oneself-to find his or her identity, “the real me.” One’s sex, race, ethnicity, religion, and physical attractiveness can play important roles in producing-or failing to produce-a consistent and acceptable self-image. This is a process of accepting one-self, as one truly is, apart from illusions, made-up images, and exaggerations. Social psychologists believe that, in the process of finding and accepting oneself during this crisis, the individual must experience recognition, a sense of control over her or his environment, and achievement. Being a member of a group intensifies these needs. Social psychologists, such as Patricia and Richard Schmuck (Schmuck & Schmuck, 1992), urge teachers to recognize that groups help provide opportunities for recognition, control, and achievement and to use this heightened motivation to achieve academic goals. And they caution that classrooms that fail to satisfy these three basic needs may contain large numbers of learners who feel rejected, listless, and powerless, creating motivational and conduct problems within the classroom. A task orientation in which the teacher plans to actively involve learners in ways they can express themselves and their uniqueness can help to meet these three basic needs. Some classroom activities that can provide your learners opportunities for recognition, control and achievement include: • Discussions • Demonstrations and exhibits • Cooperative activities • Portfolios • Project-based learning The effective teacher not only understands and emphasizes with the conflicting emotions of students at this stage but also provides the classroom structure needed to help resolve the crisis. Erikson’s third crisis during the school years is that of giving up part of one’s identity to develop close and intimate relationships with others. For some, this stage may occur after the high school years, but for most, its roots are in high school. Forming relationships, especially with the opposite sex, may be one of the most important and traumatic experiences of school. For some students in may represent the only reason for coming to school. It is not unusual for students during this crisis to form emotional relationships with their teachers as well, especially when relationships with their peers are thwarted due to differences in maturity, attractiveness, interests, or physical size. There are no simple ways to deal with these emotions. Be aware of crushes, try to cushion their impact on the student, and try to channel the student’s emotions productively. Learning how to get along with teachers, parents, and classmates is one of the key developmental tasks learners must master to successfully resolve this crisis. Successful relationships with parents and teachers, referred to as vertical relationships (Hartup, 1989), meet a learner’s needs for safety, security, and protection. Successful relationships with peers, referred to as horizontal relationships, are of equal developmental significance for learners. They meet learners’ needs for belonging and allow them to acquire and practice important social skills, “providing opportunities for learners to develop healthy relationships when they enter school helps them develop skills important in getting along with others, helping others, and establishing intimacy. The failure to experience healthy horizontal relationships and learn friendship-building attitudes and skills can have undesirable consequences. This failure is often described as social rejection. Current research suggests that rejected children are more likely to be aggressive and disruptive in school (Hartup, 1989), experience intense feelings of loneliness (Cassidy & Asher, 1992), and suffer emotional disturbances in adolescence and adulthood (T. J. Dishon, Patterson, Stoolmiller & Skinner, 1991). Nevertheless, researchers have shown that learners can be taught some of the social skills necessary to again acceptance by peers. More importantly, by helping your learners construct their own well-functioning horizontal relationships, they will acquire friendship-building attitudes and skills that can have desirable consequences in your classroom. Personality differences due to anxiety, style, and self-concept are important in all three of Erikson’s crises of the school years. Let’s see what the researchers have to say about them. Anxiety Everyone finds anxiety uncomfortable, if only because of its debilitating effect on getting things done. Anxiety makes even the simplest tasks seem difficult. One feels threatened, fearful of the unknown, and generally tense. Among your acquaintances, and perhaps within yourself, you have observed at least two types of anxiety. They are called state anxiety and trait anxiety. State Anxiety. State anxiety (Spielberger, 1966) is an experience of fear or threat related to a particular environmental situation. A common example is the anxiety felt before taking a test. This represents a state or condition that is momentary and produced by some specific stimulus in the environment (a rest, a report card, a speech before the class, a first date). Levels of state anxiety vary with different environmental stimuli. However, given the right stimulus, this anxiety can occur at any time. There is a positive side to state anxiety: some is necessary for learning. Without learning the negative consequences of a failing grade. Mary may not do the studying required for a passing grade. Without some fear of injury in a poorly executed lab experiment, Damon may not be cautions enough to avoid the danger. Without fear of doing poorly in front of his peers, Billy may not organize his speech well enough to avoid embarrassment. Evaluation or assessment in the form of grades, report cards, and assignments are some of the ways the effective teacher provides the level of state anxiety necessary to motivate students. Trait Anxiety. A second type of anxiety is a general disposition to feel threatened by a wide range of conditions perceived to be harmful. This type of anxiety has been labeled trait anxiety, indicating its stability over time. No single stimulus, such as grade or assignment, can be identified as the source of the anxiety. It results instead from many ill-defined sources. Unlike state anxiety, which all students experience to some degree, that anxiety is a fairly stable characteristic of one’s personality, with different individuals having different amounts. High levels of trait anxiety seem to go with high motivation and the need to achieve. But, like state anxiety, extremely high levels of trait anxiety can be immobilizing, especially when the need to achieve is guided more by a fear of failure (shame, ridicule by peers, punishment from parents’) rather than by a wish to do well. When fear of failure is the primary motive among high-anxiety students, they may mechanical, perfunctory way, allowing for little more than the most obvious and expected learning outcomes. Research shows that when motivation among high-anxiety students is guided more by a desire to do well (e.g., to produce a high-quality product, create something new and different, gain the respect of others, tackle the impossible) rather by than fear of failure, more work is accomplished toward a given goal in less time and in ways that engage students is discovery types of learning experiences that result in higher achievement (Covington & Omelich, 1987). This suggests that one of your tasks as an effective teacher is to tailor the learning conditions of high-anxiety students. In the case of high trait anxiety, conveying a feeling of warmth, encouragement, and support before the assignment can turn fears of failure into more productive motives involving a desire to do well. Structuring the assignment in ways that provide for a range of acceptable responses serves to focus the high-anxiety student on an attainable end product and away from general fears of being unable to achieve acceptable level of performance. As we will learn in Chapter 13, performance assessment and student portfolios are also excellent ways of accomplishing this goal. Learning Style A second aspect of personality that will influence your learners’ achievement is their learning style. Learning style refers to the classroom or environmental conditions under which someone prefers to learn. Although there are a number of learning styles, the one most studied has been that identified with the characteristics of field dependence and field independence. Field Dependence Versus Field Independence. Much has been written about how some learners are more global than analytic in how they approach learning (Franklin, 1992). Some researchers use the terms holistic/visual to describe global learners, and verbal/analytic to describe the opposite style or orientation (Tharp & Gallimore, 1989). Still others (Pilliard, 1976) prefer the term field sensitive to refer to the verbal/analytic learning style. To what are these researchers referring? Basically, these terms have come to refer to how people view the world. People who are field dependent see the world in terms of large, connected patterns. Looking at a volcano, for example, a field-dependent person would notice its overall shape, and the large colors and topographical features that make it up. A field-independent person, on the other hand, would tend to notice the discrete parts of a scene. Thus, she might notice more the individual trees, the different rocks, the size of the caldera, where the caldera sits in relation to the rest of the structure, topographical features showing the extent of lava flow, and so on. The better understand what field dependence and field independence mean, and what these terms suggest about how different children learn, let’s look at what some of the researchers say about them. Franklin (1992) and Tharp (1989) believe that field dependence and independence are stable traits of individuals that affect different aspects of their lives, especially their approach to learning. Table 2.2 summarizes some of the characteristics associated with both types of learners. These researchers agree that the different personality characteristics or traits of field-dependent and independent learners suggest that at least some learners think about and process information differently during classroom learning activities. Those authors suggest that each group would benefit from different instructional strategies, as suggested in Table 2.3. Learning Style and Culture. Educators have become interested in the relationship between learning style and culture. The work of several researchers has suggested that Native Americans, Hispanic Americans, and African Americans are more field-dependent than Anglo Americans and Asian Americans (C. Bennett, 1990; Cushner, McClelland, & Safford, 1992; Garcia, 1991; Hilliard, 1992; Tharp, 1989). These researchers advocate that teachers who work with these groups of learners use more field-dependent teaching styles. These researchers have conducted studies to answer the question of how cultural groups differ in cognitive functioning. The reasoning underlying their studies is that different ethnic and cultural groups have different informal learning or socialization practices by with they teach their children the skills necessary to adapt successfully to their environment. These practices produce certain patterns of learning styles, which influence how these children learn in formal settings. What evidence have these studies found that suggests that minority groups have different learning styles than Anglo Americans? While the evidence is sometimes inconsistent, in general, some evidence suggests that minority learners are more holistic/global/visual or field sensitive in their approach to learning than verbal/analytic or field independent. Shade (1982), Cohen (1969), and Hilliard (1976) present evidence suggesting that African American learners have a learning style emphasizing field-sensitive abilities as well as a preference for person-oriented classroom activities (cooperative learning and activities that focus on people and what they do,, rather than on things or objects). Other researchers (Knight & Kagan, 1997; Ramirez & Castaneda, 1974) conclude that Mexican Americans are more field sensitive as a group than Anglo Americans. Those authors explain the higher relative performance of this group on measures of field sensitivity by pointing out that the childrearing practices of this group stress strong family ties and a respect obedience to elders: experiences, the authors conclude, that lead to a more field-sensitive learning style. Cultural Differences in Learning Styles: Some Cautions. Is there sufficient justification to advocate field-sensitive teaching styles in classrooms with significant numbers of minority learners? Should teachers make greater use the instructional practices that emphasize cooperative learning, person and movement/action-oriented activities, visual/holistic learning, and so on when teaching significant numbers of African, Hispanic, or Native American learners? Before implementing culturally responsive teaching without qualification, keep in mind the following cautions: 1. Beware of perpetuating stereotypes. Grant (1991) cautions that cultural information such as that described previously may be used to “perpetuate ideas from the cultural deficit hypothesis that encourages teachers to believe that these students have deficits and negative differences and therefore, are not as capable of learning as white students” (P. 245). Others (Weisner, Gallimore, & Jordan, 1988) claim that cultural explanations of differential achievement of minority groups often result in global and stereotypical descriptions of how minority cultures behave that exceed available evidence, Kendall (1983) argues that is one thing to be aware of the potential effect of culture-specific learning and learning styles on classroom achievement but another to expect a child of a particular group to behave and to learn in a particular way. 2. Note within-group differences. Almost all studies of the learning style preferences of different minority groups have shown that differences within the cultural groups studied were as great as the differences between the cultural groups (Cushner et al., 1992; Henderson, 1980; Tharp, 1989). In other words, Native Americans, Hispanic Americans, African American, and Anglo Americans vary considerably on tests of field dependence and independence. Some Anglo Americans will be field independent in their pattern of scores, and some Native Americans will be field independent. On the average, the groups may differ. But, around these averages are ranges of considerable magnitude. Thus, using a field-dependent teaching style, even in a mono cultural classroom, may fail to match the preferred learning style of at least some learners. 3. Culturally responsive teaching may be more difficult in multicultural classrooms. Culturally responsive teaching appears to be most efficient and practical in mono cultural classrooms. In classrooms that are multicultural, it may be difficult, maybe impossible, to match the different learning styles of 30 or more children who may represent several different cultural. 4. Culturally responsive concerns may take the focus away from “expert practice.” Educators such as Lindsley (1992) and Englemann and Carnie (1982) argue that, before assuming that differences in achievement are due to characteristics within the learner (e.g., learning style), factors external to the learner, such as ineffective teaching practices, should be ruled out. Also, the quality of instruction provided minority learners should be equivalent to that provided Anglo Americans. Majority and minority group learners should experience similar schooling in terms of resources, quality of teachers, expectations, expert practice in instruction, testing, and motivation techniques before teachers embrace specialized techniques specifically adapted to minorities. Although some evidence indicates that African American and Native American children improve in reading and math with culturally responsive teaching techniques (Franklin, 1992; Tharp, 1989), studies fall to indicate that expert instruction using traditional instructional methods could not have achieved the same or similar results. Self-Concept A third aspect of personality that will influence your learners’ achievement is self-concept. Self-concept presents the beliefs, feelings, and studies we have about ourselves. Our self-concept grows out of interactions with significant others, such as parents, teachers, and peers. Significant others act as mirrors for our behavior. That is, they reflect the images we create of ourselves, sometimes in modified and revised form. When the image that is returned looks good, is acceptable to others, and is consistent with what we want it to be, a positive self-concept is formed. When the reflected image does not look good, is unacceptable to others, and is inconsistent with our beliefs about ourselves, a less favorable self-concept is formed. The information of self-concept is perhaps one of the most fascinating aspects of personality. It has captured the attention of many psychologist and researchers who have studied the relationship of self-concept to student achievement. The research thus far is sketchy and focuses only on certain grades and subjects. However, some evidence indicates that a positive self-concept may be moderately related to achievement (Beane, 1991; Hansford & Hattie, 1982; Walberg, 1986). This research has been taken as an encouraging sign that student’s concept of self can affect the extent to which he or she becomes actively engaged in the process of learning, and vice versa, even if it is not always strongly related to scores on tests of academic performance. Does a positive self-concept promote achievement? Or does achievement promote a positive self-concept? We don’t know. However, the intuitive value of having a positive self-concept is so pervasive in our culture that the order of the relationship may not be all that important. An increase in self-concept is believed to have positive results on behavior, either directly on school achievement or indirectly on one’s ability to relate to others, to cope with the problems of daily life, and ultimately to succeed in a career or occupational. Such important outcomes are not measures by tests of academic achievement. However, good performance on school tests might improve one’s self-concept. This, in turn could influence the other important life outcomes. This is reason enough for engaging students in the learning process at moderate-to-high rates of success: to provide a mirror with a positive image. While high rates of success are important for all students, they may be especially important to lower-SES students. These students have been found to have the poorest self-concepts, and their home life may provide few opportunities for improving them. The crucial question asked by every student in the process of forming a self-concept is “How am I being perceived?” In the school environment, this reflected self-image is derived most often from direct, personal interaction with you, the teacher. As a teacher it will be your task to be sensitive to and to be understanding of the impact of the images you reflect to students by your words and deeds. You will not always want to reflect what your students believe about themselves. On the other hand, consider that any image you send back by interaction and performance evaluations may have implications far beyond the time when you deliver the message. The message you reflect may contribute to the ever-growing complement of data used by each of your student to form the self-concept they will “wear” for years to come. The secret to improving students’ self-concepts lies in the process of finding and reflecting back to students the value of their unique talents. THE EFFECTS OF THE PEER GROUP ON LEARNING One of the most powerful but sometimes least noted influences on a student’s behavior is the peer group. Often considered as the source of a hidden curriculum, the peer group can influence and even teach students how to behave in class, study for tests, and converse with teachers and school administrators, and it can contribute to the success or failure of performance in school in many other ways. From the play group in the elementary school to the teenage clique in high school, a student learns from peers how to behave in ways that are acceptable and that will establish status in the eyes of others. Establishing such status reflects group approval, which promotes a good self-concept. The power of the peer group in influencing individual student behavior stems from the fact that it is the voluntary submission of one’s will to some larger cause. Teachers and parents must sometimes beg, plead, punish, and reward to exact appropriate behavior from their students, sons, and daughters. But peer groups need to engage in any of these behaviors to obtain a high level of conformity to often unstated and abstract principles of behavior. Trendy school fashions, new slang words, places to “hang out,” acceptable social mates, and respected forms of out-of-school activities are communicated and learned to perfection without lesson plans, texts, or even direct verbalization. Instead, these and other behaviors are transmitted by “salient others” and received by those who anxiously wish to maintain membership in or gain acceptance to a particular peer group. Friendship patterns often are created through peer groups and sometimes are adhered with strong commitments of loyalty, protection, and mutual benefit. These commitments can create individual peer cultures or even gangs within a school. Such cultures can rival the academic commitments made in classroom and frequently supersede them in importance. Studying for a rest or completing homework frequently may be sacrificed for the benefit of the peer group. Peer groups can form on the basis of many different individual differences, such as intelligence, achievement, personality, home life, physical appearance, and personal and social interest. But they commonly result from complex combinations of these that are not always discernible to outsiders and sometimes not even to those within the peer group (Hartup, 1989; Schmuck & Schmuck, 1992). The importance of peer group characteristics in the classroom lies in the extent to which they can be used to promote behaviors that enhance a member’s engagement in the learning process. Here are several approaches for constructively using peer relationships to foster classroom goals: 1. Stress group work in which members are from different peer groups. When forming work or cooperative groups, be sure group members represent different backgrounds and interests, which can bring different skills and talents to an assignment. When different types of individuals are assigned to work cooperatively, group behavior tends to follow a middle ground, discouraging extreme on disruptive behavior. 2. Conduct a group discussion of class norms, describing what class members should and should not to be socially acceptable. Tell group members what you expect of them, and give some examples of what they might expect of others. Glasser (1990) suggest discussing with students ideas on how the class might be run, problems that may interfere with the group’s performance, and needed rules and routines. 3. Build group cohesiveness by promoting the attractiveness of each student to one another. Provide opportunities for your students to know one another through one or more of the following: Construct a bulletin board around the theme of friendships; have students write a brief biography about themselves for all to read; publish a class directory that includes names, hobbies, jobs, and career aspirations; and have students bring something they have made or really care about (a toy, tool, model, etc.). 4. Assign older or more mature students are more likely to be respected as role models to interact with and help younger students in a peer tutoring situation. Many schools have a formal peer tutoring program called cross-age tutoring. In which tutors may be chosen from higher grades, to help younger students who may be at risk, or discouraged learners. Research has shown that tutoring has been most successful when tutors have been trained and given explicit instruction on how to tutor. THE EFFECTS OF THE SOCIAL CONTEXT ON LEARNING Closely connected with the influence of the peer group on learning is the social context in which your learners live, play, and work. Among the most prominent sources of influence in this context will be your learners’ family and its relationship to the school. In 1990, the National Governors Conference for educational reform set forth a formidable agenda for educators. Their agenda, updated and approved by Congress in 1994, established the following goals to be achieved by the first decade of the twenty-first century (see the next and related strategies on the Web at http//inet.ed.gov/legislation/GOALS2000/TheAct/): 1. All children in America will start school ready to learn. 2. The high school graduation rate will increase to at least 90%. 3. American students will leave grades 4, 8, and 12 having demonstrated competency over challenging subject matter in the sciences and humanities. 4. The nation’s teachers will have access to programs for professional development. 5. American students will be the best in the world in mathematics and science achievement. 6. Every adult American will be literate and will process the knowledge and skills to compete in a global economy and exercise the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. 7. Every school in America will be free of drugs and violence and will offer a disciplined environment conducive to learning. 8. Every school will promote parental involvement and participation to promote the social, emotional, and academic growth of children. A theme throughout the commentaries on the governors’ agenda was the realization that school would have to develop genuine partnerships with parents to achieve these goals. A singular focus on just teachers, parents, or administrators as the agents of reform would not produce the hoped-for result. Rather, only the active participation of parents, community groups, and educators in partnership with one another would bring about the desired objectives (Lambert, 1991). When parents and teachers become partners, not only can student achievement increase but also parents learn about you and your school. Research confirms that coordination and collaboration between home and school improve learner achievement, attitude toward school, classroom conduct, and parent and teacher morale (Cochran & Dean, 1991). Establishing genuine partnerships with the parents and guardians of your learners is as essential a teacher practice as those that involve building a cohesive classroom climate, establishing a well-managed work environment, developing goals and objectives, conducting effective instruction, and assessing student performance. The practice of parent involvement requires that you develop and strengthen throughout the school year “linking mechanisms” for parent participation and collaboration. Family-school linking mechanisms are opportunities for school and family involvement and may involve parent-teacher conferences, home visits, participation of teachers in community events, newsletters, phone calls, personal notes, volunteering as classroom aides, and the use of home-based curriculum materials. These efforts require more than just a handout sent home to parents at the beginning of the school year, an obligatory presentation during back-to-school night, or an occasional note home. The opportunities to develop and nurture linking mechanists will be the culmination of your efforts to build a successful classroom workplace. To assist in this process, Bronfenbrenner (1989) has urged us to view the family-school partnership from a systems-ecological perspective. Bronfenbrenner looks at the learner as a naturalist looks at nature-as an ecosystem. In the learner’s ecosystem, the major systems include the family, school, and peer group. One way to picture the learner’s ecosystem is as a series of concentric circles, as shown in Figure 2.5. Each of these circles and their connections has a special term. The most central layer is called the microsystem. It includes all those settings where the child lives or spends significant portions of his or her time: the family, school, classroom, day care setting, playground, and job setting if the child is old enough. Bronfenbrenner (1989) refers to these setting as subsystem. Each subsystem can be viewed within itself as a system. The school system is made up of subsystems that include teachers, administrators, support personnel, school board members, and learners. The family system includes a material, parental, sibling, and often a grandparental subsystem. The peer system includes social friendships, academic friendships, and sports or hobby friendships. The next layer of the system includes those subsystems the child does not directly experience but that affect the child because of the influence they exert on the microsystem. This layer is called the ecosystem. It may include the parents’ workplace, their friends, the PTA, the school board, and so on. Finally, both Microsystems and ecosystems exist in a larger setting called the macrosystem. This system refers to the larger culture or society in which the micro and ecosystems function. Figure 2.6 indicates some of the relationships among these systems. A systems-ecological perspective urges us to view learner’s behavior, not as a product of that individual alone, but as a product of the learner and the demands and forces operating within the systems of which the learner is a member. Family experiences and the culture of the family system influence school behavior and performance, which, in turn, affect the family system. School adjustment problems, which may be influenced by problems within the family may, in turn, exacerbate conditions within the family system itself. For example, the parent who never signs and returns a note home may not be an uninterested and uninvolved parent-as might be assumed. Dynamics within the family system (e.g., other siblings who demand extensive care or adjustment to a new child) may explain the parents’ apparent back of involvement in their child’s education. Thus, when trying to understand the behavior of parents, teachers, and learners, the systems-ecological perspective recommends that we first ask ourselves “what forces within the family-school environment impel the person to act this way?” When the goal is to promote the academic and social development of the learner, the systems-ecological perspective focuses our most immediate concern on the family-school partnership. Here are some guidelines for understanding and promoting family-school partnership in your classroom. 1. View the family from a systems-ecological perspective. Avoid viewing the behavior of your learners or their mothers or fathers, as simply products of individual psychological forces. Instead, recognize that the family system is made up of several subsystems, including the material subsystem, parental subsystem, the sibling subsystem, and extrafamily or ecosystem such as grandparents and employers. Changes in one subsystem inevitably bring about changes in the other. Asking parents to take greater responsibility for getting their child to bed earlier at night can result in an argument at home between husband and wife, punishment of the child, teasing by siblings, and concern and criticism by in-laws. Likewise, demands by school staff that parents do something at home to make the child complete homework inevitably reverberate throughout the entire family system. These effects may be great as to preclude any change in parental behavior. 2. Acknowledge changes in the American family. Most families have two working parents. Research on teacher beliefs regarding families where both parents work shows that teacher believe that working parents are less involved with their children’s education (Linney & Vernberg, 1983). However, a study conducted by Medrich, Roizen, Rubin, and Burkley (1982) concludes that working and nonworking mother’s spend the same amount of time in child-related activities. Furthermore, their data show that children of working mothers are just as involved in extracurricular activities as are the children of nonworking mothers. Single-parent families make up about 25% of the families of schoolchildren. Yet many teachers view this family pattern as an abnormality (Carlson, 1992). Joyce Epstein, a researcher at the Johns Hopkins Center for researcher on Elementary and Middle Schools, reports that teachers have lower expectations for the achievement of children from single-parent families despite the fact that no data support this (Epstein, 1987). Some researchers suggest that the requirements in single-parent families for organization, schedules, routines, and division of responsibilities better prepare children to accept such structure in schools (Linney & Vernberg, 1983). 3. View parent participation from an empowerment model rather than a deficit model. Delgado-Gaitan (1991) and Valencia (1997) propose that we view parent participation as a process that involves giving parents both the power and the knowledge to deal with the school system. Typically deficit model explanations have been offered for reasons why culturally different parents have not become involved with schools. These perspectives sometimes have portrayed parents as passive, incompetent, or unskilled. They propose that parents are unable to become involved I their children’s education because they work long hours away from the home or simply not interested. But, Delgado-Gaitan (1992) points out, when examined closely, research has shown that Hispanic families who speak a different language and have a different culture from that of the school do indeed care about their children and process the capacity to advocate for them. This holds true for African Americans, Native Americans, and other cultural and linguistic groups as well. The question is not can they become genuine partners with the school but how to empower them to do so. 4. Recognize the unique needs of mothers and fathers when planning opportunities to involve parents. Turnbull and Turnbull (1986) urge teachers to promote nonsexist views of parent involvement. They stress that teachers recognize the importance of mothers and fathers when designing home-school linkages. Encourage visiting opportunities for both parents, and develop flexible schedules to accommodate the working schedules of both parents. Send information about the children and schooling to both parents. Seek to promote teaching skills in fathers as well as mothers. Finally, give consideration to the father’s interests and needs when suggesting ways for parents to work with their children at home. 5. Appreciate that parents are just like you-they experience periodic emotional, family, and economic problems. Many parents way have personal, family, work, health, or other problems that remind hidden. Make a special effort to provide the benefit of the doubt, particularly when parents fail to respond in a timely manner to your requests. Carlson (1992) documents the overwhelming economic as well as divorce, custody, and career problems of single parents. Their failure to monitor their child’s homework, or attendance, or tardiness to class may be due less to a lack of interest than to attempts to cope with day-to-day problems. When parents do not live up to your expectations, avoid trying to assign personal blame. 6. Understand the variety of school-family linkages, and respect family preferences for different degrees of school participation. As you are planning for parent involvement early in the school year, consider and evaluate the full range of ways in which parents can participate. These activities can be placed on a continuum anchored on one end by activities that involve parents as receivers of information (parent-teacher conference, notes home, classroom newsletter) and on the other end by activities that involve parents as active educational decision makers (school and classroom advisory councils, site-based management teams, tutoring). Developing partnerships with the parents of your learners should be as much a focus of your planning for a new school year as your classroom rules, routines, instructional goals, and objectives. As the research suggests, your learners’ achievement of academic goals, their adherence to rules and routines, and their attitudes and expectations about school can be enhanced by having parents as partners. PLANNING TO ELIMINATE BIAS Much of what has been said about individual differences suggests that planning to eliminate bias in classroom teaching can be one of the most significant aspects of becoming an affective teacher. Researchers recently have brought to our attention that, consciously, everyone has biases of one kind or another (Gage & Berliner, 1992). When applied in ways that affect only your own behavior and not that of others, we use the word preference. Biases, on the other hand, are not harmless; they can injure the personal growth and well-being of others and if left unchecked, can significantly affect the growth and development of learners. Let’s look at some of the ways you might show bias. Biases in Labeling and Grouping A particularly alarming case of bias was uncovered by Rist (1970) when he studied a single class of lower SES students from kindergarten through second grade. Rist observed that from the time these students entered kindergarten, they were divided into three groups-Tigers, Cardinals, and Clowns-each seated at a different table. Initial placement into these groups in kindergarten was made by the teacher according to SES, using information from registration forms and from interviews with mothers and social workers. The highest status children, called Tigers, were seated closest to the teacher and quickly labeled fast learners. The lowest status children, called Clowns, were farthest removed from the teacher and quickly were led to believe they were slow learners. In reality, each of the three groups had a mixture of slow and fast learners; but the slow learners seated farthest from the teacher seldom got the opportunity to interact with her, while those closest to the teacher frequently received attention. Before long, the abilities of each group were taken as fact farther than as creations of the teacher, do much so that it was increasingly difficult for the Clowns to be considered other than slow by their teachers in the following grades. At no time did the teacher seem to be aware that the arrangement was biased or that seating certain students consistently in the back of the room would reduce their contact with her. Thus, this teacher’s bias became a self-fulfilling prophecy that extended even to subsequent grades and classes-all as a result of biased labeling during the early years of schooling. Many other examples of teacher biases have been catalogued. For example, Good & Brophy (1997) summarize how teachers sometimes respond unequally to high and low achievers by communicating low expectations and thereby accepting, and unintentionally encouraging, a low level of performance among some students. They identified the following areas in which some teachers responded differently toward low and high achieves: • Wait less time for low achievers to answer. • Give low achievers the answer after their slightest hesitation. • Praise marginal or inaccurate answers of low achievers. • Criticize low achievers more frequently for having the wrong answer. • Praise low achievers less when the right answer is given. • Do not give feedback to low achievers as to why an answer is incorrect. • Pay attention to (e.g., smile at) and call on low achievers less. • Seat low achievers farther from the teacher. • Allow low achievers to give up more. Generally, these findings confirm that teachers usually do not compensate for differences between high and low achievers in allowing more response opportunities more teacher contact for low achievers. Biases in Interacting Other types of bias can affect interactions with students. For example, Gage and Berliner (1992) identified several biased ways in which teachers interact with their students and then analyzed the extent to which experienced teachers actually exhibited these biases in their classrooms. Their biases included interacting with or calling on students disproportionately in these ways: • Seated in front of class versus seated in back half of class • Nicer-looking students versus average-looking students • More-able students versus less-able students • Nonminority group members versus minority group members Gage and Berliner (1992) calculated the number of student-teacher interactions that would be expected by chance for these classifications, and then from observation they determined the actual number of interactions that occurred. Somewhat surprisingly, their results indicate that every teacher showed some bias in these categories. In other words, every teacher favored at least one student classification over another by naming, calling on, requiring information from, and otherwise interacting with those in some classification disproportionally to those not in that classification. Such biases may be meaningless over a single class period but can have significant and long-lasting emotional impact on students if continued throughout weeks, months, or the entire school year. The accumulated effect of systematic bias in a classroom is an open message to some students that they are less desirable and less worthy of attention than others, regardless of how unintentional the bias may be. The result of these biased messages is change in motivation, self-concept, and anxiety level of some students in ways that impede their development and learning. Bias in the way a teacher interacts with students is undesirable in any form, but it is particularly distasteful when it pertains to students’ ethnicity. Our nation and our educational system are based on the respect for individual differences of all types. This means that our classrooms become one of the most important showplaces of our democratic values. It is disturbing that researchers report frequent ethnic classrooms. Studies (D. Dillon, 1989; Tharp 7 Gallimore, 1989) point out that many actions of teachers diminish the classroom participation of minority students and/or build resentment because the teachers’ actions are culturally incongruent. Bowers and Flinders (1991) and Gage and Berliner (1992) provide the following suggestions for eliminating bias and increasing cultural sensitivity in the classroom: 1. Plan to spread your interactions as evenly as possible across student categories by deciding in advance which students to call on. Because the many classifications of potential bias are cumbersome to deal with, choose one or two bias categories you know or suspect you are most vulnerable to. 2. If you plan on giving special assignments to only some of your students, choose the students randomly. Place all of your students’ names in a jar, and have one student draw the names of individuals needed for the special assignment. This protects you from inadvertently choosing the same students repeatedly and conveying the impression that you have pets. 3. Try consciously to pair opposites in what you believe to be a potential area of bias for you; for example, pair minority with nonminority, more able with less able, easy to work with and difficult to work with, and so on. In this manner, when you are interacting with one member of the pair, you will be reminded to interact with the other. Occasionally change one member of the pair so that your pairing does not become obvious to the class. 4. When you discover a bias, plan a code to remind you of the bias and then embed it within your class notes, text, or lesson plan at appropriate intervals. For example, should you discover you systematically favor more able learners over less able learners, place a code on the margins of your exercise to remind you to choose a less able for the next response.

0 komentar:

Posting Komentar